Comparative Evaluation of the Vaccine Efficacies of Three Adenovirus-Based Vector Types in the Friend Retrovirus Infection Model.

Abstract

Adenovirus (AdV)-based vectors are popular experimental vaccine vectors, but despite their ability to induce strong immune responses, their application is impeded by widespread preexisting immunity against many AdV types that can impair or even abrogate the induction of transgene-specific immune responses. Therefore, the development of vectors based on AdV types with a low seroprevalence is important for effective AdV-based immunization in humans. We investigated the immunization efficacy of vectors based on AdV type 48 (Ad48) and Ad50 in the ovalbumin (ova) model as well as the Friend retrovirus (FV) model, which allows testing of the protective effect of vaccine-induced immunity. Using ova-encoding vectors, we found a significantly lower induction of ova-specific CD8+ T cells and antibody responses by Ad48- and Ad50-based vectors than by Ad5-based vectors. Similarly, we found a reduced induction of FV-specific CD8+ T cell responses in Ad48- and Ad50.Leader-Gag-immunized mice compared with that in Ad5-immunized mice; however, some of those mice were able to control the FV infection, and protection correlated with the level of neutralizing antibodies 10 days after FV challenge. Analyses of the AdV-specific antibodies and CD8+ T cells induced by the individual AdV types revealed a high level of cross-reactivity, and the efficacy of Ad48-based immunization was impaired in Ad5-preimmune mice. Our results show that the immunity induced by Ad48- and Ad50-based vectors is reduced compared to that induced by Ad5 and is sufficient to control FV infection in only some of the immunized mice. A high level of cross-reactivity suggests that AdV preimmunity must be considered even when applying rare AdV-based vectors.IMPORTANCE AdV-based vectors are important tools for the development of vaccines against a wide range of pathogens. While AdV vectors are generally considered safe and highly effective, their application can be severely impaired by preexisting immunity due to the widespread seroprevalence of some AdV types. The characterization of different AdV types with regard to immunogenicity and efficacy in challenge models is of great importance for the development of improved AdV-based vectors that allow for efficient immunization despite anti-AdV immunity. We show that the immunity induced by an Ad48-based vector is inferior to that induced by an Ad5-based vector but can still mediate the control of an FV infection in highly FV-susceptible mice. However, the efficacy of Ad48-based immunization was impaired in Ad5-preimmune mice. Importantly, we found cross-reactivity of both the humoral and cellular immune responses raised by the individual AdV types, suggesting that switching to a different AdV type may not be sufficient to circumvent preexisting anti-AdV immunity.

• Authors: Camilla Patrizia Hrycak, Sonja Windmann, Wibke Bayer
• Journal: Journal of virology (J Virol) Vol. 93 Issue 21 (11 01 2019) ISSN: 1098-5514 [Electronic] United States
• PMID: 31375593 (Publication Type: Comparative Study, Evaluation Study, Journal Article, Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't)
• Copyright: Copyright © 2019 American Society for Microbiology.

Chemical References

• Adenovirus Vaccines
• Antibodies, Viral
• Antigens, Viral
• Ovalbumin

Topics

• Adenoviridae (classification, immunology)
• Adenoviridae Infections (immunology, prevention & control, virology)
• Adenovirus Vaccines (administration & dosage, immunology)
• Animals
• Antibodies, Viral (immunology)
• Antigens, Viral (immunology)
• CD8-Positive T-Lymphocytes (immunology, virology)
• Female
• Genetic Vectors (administration & dosage)
• Humans
• Immunity, Cellular (immunology)
• Immunization
• Mice
• Mice, Inbred BALB C
• Ovalbumin (immunology)
• Retroviridae (immunology)
• Retroviridae Infections (immunology, prevention & control, virology)