Hypothesis-based weight-of-evidence evaluation and risk assessment for naphthalene carcinogenesis.

Abstract

Inhalation of naphthalene causes olfactory epithelial nasal tumors in rats (but not in mice) and benign lung adenomas in mice (but not in rats). The limited available human data have not identified an association between naphthalene exposure and increased respiratory cancer risk. Assessing naphthalene's carcinogenicity in humans, therefore, depends entirely on experimental evidence from rodents. We evaluated the respiratory carcinogenicity of naphthalene in rodents, and its potential relevance to humans, using our Hypothesis-Based Weight-of-Evidence (HBWoE) approach. We systematically and comparatively reviewed data relevant to key elements in the hypothesized modes of action (MoA) to determine which is best supported by the available data, allowing all of the data from each realm of investigation to inform interpretation of one another. Our analysis supports a mechanism that involves initial metabolism of naphthalene to the epoxide, followed by GSH depletion, cytotoxicity, chronic inflammation, regenerative hyperplasia, and tumor formation, with possible weak genotoxicity from downstream metabolites occurring only at high cytotoxic doses, strongly supporting a non-mutagenic threshold MoA in the rat nose. We also conducted a dose-response analysis, based on the likely MoA, which suggests that the rat nasal MoA is not relevant in human respiratory tissues at typical environmental exposures. Our analysis illustrates how a thorough WoE evaluation can be used to support a MoA, even when a mechanism of action cannot be fully elucidated. A non-mutagenic threshold MoA for naphthalene-induced rat nasal tumors should be considered as a basis to determine human relevance and to guide regulatory and risk-management decisions.

• Authors: Lisa A Bailey, Marc A Nascarella, Laura E Kerper, Lorenz R Rhomberg
• Journal: Critical reviews in toxicology (Crit Rev Toxicol) Vol. 46 Issue 1 Pg. 1-42 ( 2016) ISSN: 1547-6898 [Electronic] England
• PMID: 26202831 (Publication Type: Journal Article, Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't, Review)

Chemical References

• Naphthalenes
• naphthalene

Topics

• Administration, Inhalation
• Animals
• Carcinogenesis
• DNA Damage (drug effects)
• Dose-Response Relationship, Drug
• Environmental Exposure (adverse effects)
• Humans
• Lung Neoplasms (blood, chemically induced)
• Models, Animal
• Naphthalenes (pharmacokinetics, toxicity)
• Risk Assessment