Diphtheria-tetanus overimmunization in children with no records: can it be prevented?

Abstract

A pilot study was undertaken to assess the validity of two new tests for predicting the immune response of Toronto schoolchildren with no acceptable evidence of prior administration of diphtheria or tetanus toxoid to a routine booster injection of diphtheria and tetanus (DT) toxoid. The tests, an inexpensive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) fingerprick test for tetanus antibodies and a modification of the Schick skin test for susceptibility to diphtheria, were administered before the booster injection. One week later the ELISA test was repeated and the result of the modified Schick test read. On both occasions a diphtheria microneutralization assay was done for "gold standard" evidence of prior exposure to diphtheria toxoid or toxin. The results were used to determine the sensitivity and specificity of a single prebooster tetanus ELISA test or a modified Schick test for predicting which children with no records could be safely protected with only one DT booster dose instead of the primary series of three or four doses usually given to such children. Only 6 of the 34 subjects (18%) were totally without prior exposure to tetanus toxoid. Two of the six (6% of 33 subjects) appeared to mount a primary immune response to diphtheria toxoid as well. An initial ELISA titre of 0.01 IU/ml or lower correctly identified all six children needing a full series of tetanus toxoid (sensitivity for a primary immune response 100%) and falsely identified only 3 of 28 immune children as needing the series (specificity for immunity 89.3%). The modified Schick test appeared to have even greater accuracy for identifying children needing a full series of diphtheria toxoid. However, its use, entailing the costs of an extra nurse visit, would have prevented only seven more children from receiving an unnecessary full series of diphtheria toxoid than use of the baseline tetanus ELISA test alone.

• Authors: J W Frank, R Schabas, R Arshinoff, R Brant
• Journal: CMAJ : Canadian Medical Association journal = journal de l'Association medicale canadienne (CMAJ) Vol. 141 Issue 12 Pg. 1241-6 (Dec 15 1989) ISSN: 0820-3946 [Print] Canada
• PMID: 2590890 (Publication Type: Journal Article, Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't)

Chemical References

• Antibodies, Bacterial
• Diphtheria Toxoid
• Tetanus Toxoid

Topics

• Adolescent
• Antibodies, Bacterial (analysis)
• Child
• Child, Preschool
• Diphtheria (immunology)
• Diphtheria Toxoid (administration & dosage)
• Disease Susceptibility
• Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay
• Female
• Humans
• Male
• Ontario
• Pilot Projects
• Records
• Reproducibility of Results
• Skin Tests (methods)
• Tetanus (immunology)
• Tetanus Toxoid (administration & dosage)
• Vaccination