A clinical trial of N-[4-hydroxyphenyl]
retinamide (4-HPR) has been in progress for the past 4 years to evaluate its role in
chemoprevention of
breast cancer. However, it is currently not known whether the effect of
4-HPR in breast cells is mediated by
4-HPR directly or through one of its metabolites. In this report, we investigated in vivo and in vitro effects of
4-HPR on three different
breast carcinoma cells and two different
melanoma cell lines. In vitro, the growth of all three
breast carcinoma cell lines was inhibited by
4-HPR. Only one of two
melanoma cell lines (UISO-Mel-1) showed growth inhibition to
4-HPR. The cell lines sensitive to
4-HPR in vitro also showed inhibition to
4-HPR in a xenograft model. Dietary
4-HPR (0.5 mmol/kg diet) reduced the growth of UISO-BCA-1 xenografts in female athymic mice, but had no effect on UISO-Mel-6 xenografts. Metabolism investigations of the 4-HPR-sensitive and insensitive cell lines indicated that N-[4-methoxyphenyl]
retinamide (4-MPR), the major metabolite of
4-HPR, was detected only in cells sensitive to
4-HPR. Further in vitro studies with
4-MPR suggested that it is not an active metabolite of
4-HPR as it failed to inhibit growth of 4-HPR-resistant UISO-Mel-6 cells, and showed no dose-dependent inhibition of 4-HPR-sensitive
breast carcinoma and
melanoma cell lines. Our results in the present study indicate that, although
4-MPR is not an active metabolite of
4-HPR, detection of this metabolite in the malignant cells may serve as an indirect
biomarker to predict response of cells to
4-HPR.