Quinolones versus macrolides in the treatment of legionellosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis.

Abstract

BACKGROUND:

Legionellosis is a life-threatening disease. The clinical superiority of quinolones or macrolides for treating patients with legionellosis has not been established.

METHODS:

We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies reporting data that allowed the comparison of quinolones versus macrolides in the treatment of proven legionellosis published from 1 January 1985 to 31 January 2013. We collected baseline aggregate patient characteristics. Studied outcomes included mortality, clinical cure, time to apyrexia, length of hospital stay and occurrence of complications in each treatment group. Treatment effect was assessed using a Mantel-Haenszel random effects model.

RESULTS:

Among 1005 abstracts reviewed, 12 studies were selected (n=879 patients). No randomized controlled trial was performed directly comparing quinolone and macrolide efficacy in legionellosis. Mean age was 58.3 years, 27.7% were women and Fine score was ≥ 4 in 35.8%. Among 253 patients who received quinolone monotherapy, 10 died (4.0%). Among 211 patients who received macrolide monotherapy, 23 died (10.9%). The pooled OR of death for treatment with a quinolone versus a macrolide was 0.5 (95% CI 0.2-1.3, n=8 studies, 464 patients). Length of stay was significantly shorter in the quinolone monotherapy group. The difference was 3.0 days (95% CI 0.7-5.3, P=0.001, n=3 studies, 263 patients). Neither of two tests for heterogeneity was significant (I (2)=0% for both, P=1). Other studied outcomes were not significantly different among treatment groups.

CONCLUSIONS:

Few clinical data on legionellosis treatment are available. This first meta-analysis showed a trend toward a lower mortality rate and a significant decrease in length of hospital stay among patients receiving quinolones. These results must be confirmed by a randomized controlled trial.

• Authors: C Burdet, R Lepeule, X Duval, M Caseris, C Rioux, J-C Lucet, Y Yazdanpanah
• Journal: The Journal of antimicrobial chemotherapy (J Antimicrob Chemother) Vol. 69 Issue 9 Pg. 2354-60 (Sep 2014) ISSN: 1460-2091 [Electronic] England
• PMID: 24827889 (Publication Type: Comparative Study, Journal Article, Meta-Analysis, Review, Systematic Review)
• Copyright: © The Author 2014. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the British Society for Antimicrobial Chemotherapy. All rights reserved. For Permissions, please e-mail: [email protected].

Chemical References

• Anti-Bacterial Agents
• Macrolides
• Quinolones

Topics

• Anti-Bacterial Agents (therapeutic use)
• Humans
• Legionellosis (complications, drug therapy)
• Length of Stay
• Macrolides (therapeutic use)
• Quinolones (therapeutic use)
• Survival Analysis
• Treatment Outcome