We had previously shown that 10,11-methylenedioxy-20-(RS)-camptothecin (
MDO-CPT) is a more potent inhibitor of purified
DNA topoisomerase I than 20-(S)-camptothecin (
CPT). The current studies compared the cytotoxicity and DNA damage induced by
MDO-CPT and
CPT in the human colon
carcinoma cell line, HT-29.
MDO-CPT was 7- to 10-fold more potent than
CPT both for cytotoxicity (ID50 = 25 vs. 180 nM) and production of
DNA single-strand breaks (SSB). Kinetics of SSB formation and reversal were similar for
MDO-CPT and
CPT.
DNA-
protein crosslinks (DPC) were also produced by both drugs with a SSB/DPC ratio of 1/1. Moreover, no SSB were detected under non-deproteinizing conditions, indicating that both
CPT and
MDO-CPT produced
protein-linked
DNA single-strand breaks. A good correlation between cytotoxic potency and
protein-linked
DNA single-strand break production was observed for
CPT and
MDO-CPT, implying a causal relationship between
drug-induced cytotoxicity and
topoisomerase I inhibition. The sensitivity of human colon HT-29
cancer cells to camptothecins may be a selective phenomenon since these cells normally express natural resistance to current chemotherapeutic drugs, including
topoisomerase II inhibitors.