Load-fatigue performance of gold crowns luted with resin cements.

Abstract

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM:

Resin cements have gained popularity over the past few years because of their improved physical properties. There is a need to test these cements under fatigue loading, as there is growing recognition that fatigue testing is more clinically relevant than traditional monotonic static tests.

PURPOSE:

This study investigated the load-fatigue performance of complete gold crowns cemented with 4 types of resin cement.

MATERIAL AND METHODS:

Four resin cements (C & B Opaque [CBO], Calibra Esthetic [CE], RelyX Unicem [RU], and Panavia F [PF]) and a control, zinc phosphate cement (HY-Bond [HBZPC]) were tested. Fifty human maxillary premolars were prepared to an occluso-cervical dimension of 4 mm and a convergence angle of 20 degrees. Complete gold crowns were cast (Strator 3) and cemented with 1 of the 5 cements (n=10). A fatigue load of 73.5 N was applied at an angle of 135 degrees to the long axis of each tooth-crown specimen. Preliminary failure was defined as the propagation of a crack in or around the crown luting cement layer. The number of cycles to preliminary failure and the cement failure location were determined. Significant differences in cycles to preliminary failure were assessed by the nonparametric Kruskal-Wallis test, with follow-up Mann-Whitney tests (alpha=.05).

RESULTS:

Group CE had the highest rank of cycles to preliminary failure, while HBZPC had the lowest cycles to preliminary failure. Group CE had a significantly higher failure cycle count compared to PF (P=.016), RU (P=.001), and HBZPC (P<.001), but was not significantly different from CBO (P=.112). There was no significant difference in the failure cycle count between RU and HBZPC (P=.070).

CONCLUSION:

Not all tested resin cements had a superior fatigue life when compared with zinc phosphate cement. Of the 4 resin cement groups, Groups CE, CBO, and PF were significantly superior to HBZPC.

• Authors: Joanne Ngo Uy, Jennifer Neo Chiew Lian, Jack Ivan Nicholls, Keson Beng-Choon Tan
• Journal: The Journal of prosthetic dentistry (J Prosthet Dent) Vol. 95 Issue 4 Pg. 315-22 (Apr 2006) ISSN: 0022-3913 [Print] United States
• PMID: 16616130 (Publication Type: Comparative Study, Journal Article, Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't)

Chemical References

• Resin Cements

Topics

• Crowns
• Dental Bonding (methods)
• Dental Prosthesis Retention (methods)
• Dental Restoration Failure
• Humans
• Resin Cements (chemistry)
• Statistics, Nonparametric
• Weight-Bearing